1. More thoughts on fandom social conservatism (re: Attack the Block)

    The way that Attack the Block hasn’t permeated the Internet/”fandoms” in the way that a tight, cool, fun cult SF film should reveals a lot about the thinking of many consumers of that genre.

    The main thing is a big fat vein of social conservatism, which is more of a feature of Science Fiction/Fantasy texts (and enthusiasts) than many might admit. The response to this film’s main characters—poor, mostly black inner city youths—is often couched in the language of ghettoisation. Here’s two comments on the film’s YouTube trailer, both posted in the last week:

    "if the main protagonists were not cool gangbang badass kids the movie would be worth a 8/10 for me but in this state I just cant bare to give it some solid score"

    "Can’t stand chavs/chav talk lol, sole reason I avoided this film"

    This wholesale dismissal of the film because of this feature of its script—which the director developed by spending months working with young people who lived in these areas of London, and which the spectacularly talented but mostly non-professional-actor cast also helped to develop—is both depressing and somewhat alarming.

    Note here that the resistance to the film’s dialogue is expressed using off-the-peg cultural stereotypes (“gangbang”, “chav”) that are regularly used to dehumanise and dismiss the social legitimacy of large sections of (already marginalised) people. They’re not people, they’re gangbangers, they’re chavs; listen to how they talk. Ugh lol i can’t believe someone made a movie about them.

    There’s also an enormous double standard going on here regarding the way that people perceive the sympathetic nature of “morally ambiguous” characters. There’s no getting past the fact (and nor should there be, necessarily) that the main characters in Attack the Block are petty criminals, who mug people and threaten them in the street. But they are also complex, human characters capable of taking responsibility for their actions and making difficult, courageous decisions (indeed, that journey is one of the story arcs of the movie). And yet, they’re just gangbangers; they’re just chavs.

    But I’m willing to be that a lot of people who dismiss Attack the Block on this basis are the same people who praise to the skies the character of The Joker, or Moriarty, or some other cartoon (but much more murderous) villain. So it seems that moral ambiguity and criminal characters are fine, as long as that ambiguity is telegraphed in huge primary colours with clown makeup and campy, OTT performances by actors who are already established as respectable and mainstream.

    I have more thoughts about this but I’m struggling to articulate them right now.

     

     

     

     

     
  1. milominderbindered likes this
  2. ottery likes this
  3. pirategirlfriends likes this
  4. sebvael reblogged this from cumberbatchs
  5. heisenbergbitches likes this
  6. sundaeflowers likes this
  7. purgatorist likes this
  8. goodmenfall likes this
  9. solsolisetnoxnoctis reblogged this from aantifreeze
  10. souveraines likes this
  11. quievi likes this
  12. mythtakens likes this
  13. onlyaskeleton likes this
  14. saiths likes this
  15. getyourpjs reblogged this from pruvia
  16. pearlscaled likes this
  17. pruvia reblogged this from oryxs
  18. bahoreal reblogged this from cumberbatchs and added:
    link to the imdb page
  19. bahoreal likes this
  20. pinkmnz reblogged this from oryxs
  21. pinkmnz likes this
  22. neutrophile likes this
  23. that-kid-with-the-long-coat likes this
  24. sherlockian-1881 likes this
  25. holmestuckk reblogged this from cumberbatchs
  26. supernatyral reblogged this from cumberbatchs
  27. supernatyral likes this
  28. itsthesolarsystem likes this
  29. errantcohle likes this
  30. prufrocking likes this
  31. cumberbatchs reblogged this from oryxs
  32. oryxs reblogged this from aantifreeze
  33. pinchevangogh likes this
  34. oryxs likes this
  35. femscum likes this
  36. aantifreeze reblogged this from theumbrellaseller
  37. alexandriaofwar reblogged this from thegenderqueeralchemist
  38. n3ongold3n likes this
  39. lymantriidae likes this
  40. doesntafraid likes this
  41. she-who-shines reblogged this from thegenderqueeralchemist
  42. bravenazar likes this
  43. roseycheshire reblogged this from stonelionhearts
  44. stonelionhearts reblogged this from werewolfau
  45. silnei likes this
  46. thegenderqueeralchemist reblogged this from reblogfornoreason
  47. nevercatchcolds reblogged this from slaymonstersarchive
  48. argentarachnids reblogged this from milesabovepeter
  49. theskoomacat likes this
  50. princettemiles likes this